Walt Disney World has revealed that Nation Bear Jamboree has seen its visitor satisfaction (GSAT) rating soar for the reason that reimagined “Musical” model of the stage present debuted final summer season in Magic Kingdom. This shares particulars concerning the greater attraction approval score, together with commentary about GSATs and why this enchancment is stunning, whereas others will not be. Plus, my belated Nation Bear Musical Jamboree assessment.
Beginning with that final level, it’s typically unsurprising that sure choices which might be unpopular with followers are in style with most people. The one that stands out most prominently in my thoughts is Disney Enchantment. From the day it debuted, I made no secret that I used to be not a fan of the Disney Enchantment fireworks. I used to be overtly rooting for the fireworks to flop, with the hope that decrease visitor satisfaction scores that might consequence within the return of Fortunately Ever After.
The chances have been in opposition to that taking place, as there’s a excessive flooring for Magic Kingdom fireworks and low want inside Disney to confess defeat. All Magic Kingdom fireworks exhibits the identical core qualities, with pyro exploding over Cinderella Fortress to conclude an extended, memory-filled day at Walt Disney World. The music is pulled from sentimental moments in memorable motion pictures. These fireworks tug on the heartstrings, eliciting robust feelings and filling friends with happiness on the finish of the night.
Suffice to say, there’s a minimal baseline for any Magic Kingdom nighttime spectacular, and even an arguably “unhealthy” one remains to be “good” within the grand scheme of issues. Visitor satisfaction scores for Disney Enchantment mirrored this, and it nonetheless ranked extremely amongst all Magic Kingdom experiences. And but, it was changed as a result of it underperformed for its class. I don’t know if it was the lowest-rated Magic Kingdom nighttime spectacular ever, but it surely was under Fortunately Ever After, which is #1.
Some followers aren’t going to love listening to this, but it surely’s my understanding that it’s the same story with Tiana’s Bayou Journey. That reimagined experience has obtained combined opinions from followers, and that’s placing it charitably. This consists of our personal prolonged Tiana’s Bayou Journey Trip Evaluate: Failure, Flawed or Improbable? Or should you’d favor a comparability to its predecessor, there’s We Rode Splash Mountain & Tiana’s Bayou Journey in a Week. Right here’s How Each Win. (Spoiler: Splash Mountain wins extra.)
From what I’ve heard, common friends are unbothered by the entire faults followers have discovered. Tiana’s Bayou Journey is without doubt one of the top-rated rides not simply in Magic Kingdom, however in all of Walt Disney World. Whereas I’d love some extra element and specificity about this to grasp how downtime and reliability issue (or don’t), I’m however unsurprised.
An enormous a part of the core enchantment of that log flume experience is and has all the time been its wonderful experience profile, with outside and indoor scenes, all culminating in that climactic drop on the finish. Lovable animals and Audio Animatronics additionally issue into the combo with each incarnations of the attraction. Disney diehards can quibble over the creative and storytelling deserves of every, however common friends are largely zooming out and looking out on the greater image. They rated Splash Mountain extremely, in order that they fee Tiana’s Bayou Journey extremely.
To be clear, I’m not endorsing this–simply reporting it. Typically talking, this thought course of issues me. It’s the kind of sentiment that permits Disney to lower element or justify degrading thematic integrity underneath the guise of visitor preferences or the excuse that standard guests gained’t discover. Whereas true within the vacuum of a person attraction or two, I do suppose informal friends do discover in mixture, even when subconsciously.
Or no less than, so I’d wish to suppose. However this isn’t actually about Tiana’s Bayou Journey in any respect–it’s about precedent. In terms of that particular experience reimagining, persuasive circumstances may be made each for and in opposition to it versus its predecessor. However I digress.
Talking of Frontierland reimaginings, Disney shared an replace on Nation Bear Musical Jamboree’s visitor satisfaction rating throughout a current occasion I attended. The wide-ranging presentation was largely oriented across the “Disney Bubble,” however touched upon a wide range of completely different subjects–together with experience reimaginings.
Throughout that, Jason Kirk, Senior Vice President of Operations for Walt Disney World, shared his workforce makes use of a combination of on-the-ground interactions with friends and information to make selections. He defined how this drives programming selections, balancing near-term and long-term additions whereas additionally assessing what to refresh. “We have now to attempt to make one of the best determination for all our friends,” Kirk mentioned.
This segued into experience reimaginings, and the announcement that Magic Kingdom shall be overhauling and enhancing its model of Buzz Lightyear’s Area Ranger Spin later this 12 months. “That is us going again and saying, ‘You already know what? This expertise wants some love. It’s the OG,” mentioned Michael Hundgen, Portfolio Government Inventive Producer. “It is a nice replace to a traditional attraction at Magic Kingdom.”
Hundgen used Nation Bear Musical Jamboree as an illustrative instance. He mentioned that there have been “a number of opinions about what to do” with the present, hinting on the rumored proposals for the attraction from the Chapek period. “Followers love the bears, we love the bears,” Hundgen added. He defined that Imagineering wished to make the present contemporary and related, whereas additionally displaying like to the Nation Bears.
The presentation revealed that Walt Disney World and Imagineering take into account the reimagined stage present a “huge success.” Visitor Satisfaction surveys rank Nation Bear Musical Jamboree because the #6 general attraction in Magic Kingdom. The unique Nation Bear Jamboree was ranked #27.
That is each stunning and unsurprising.
As a lot as I’d wish to imagine in any other case, it’s no shock that the unique Nation Bear Jamboree ranked so low. It was a stage present (strike one) from the Seventies (strike two) with none connections to recognizable mental property (strike three). It additionally featured sharp wit and wry humor that almost all friends both wouldn’t recognize or would possibly discover offensive (strikes four-plus).
I liked Nation Bear Jamboree, however acknowledge that not everyone seems to be me. No quantity of consciousness or advocacy for the OG Nation Bears goes to persaud folks of my perspective. Despite the fact that I don’t like the thought of dumbing issues down for contemporary sensibilities, I’m additionally a realist. I acknowledge you need to meet the viewers the place they’re, no less than to some extent. It’s a fragile steadiness–and the identical cause why I got here to just accept that Maelstrom, Universe of Power, and even Nice Film Trip have been on borrowed time on the finish of their runs. No sense tilting at windmills.
The stunning half is that Nation Bear Musical Jamboree now ranks #6. It’s nonetheless a stage present, which I’d’ve assumed is like the precise reverse of a Magic Kingdom nighttime spectacular–one thing with a low ceiling versus a excessive flooring. For those who informed me Nation Bear Jamboree ranked #27 and requested me to guess the rating of the redone Nation Bear Musical Jamboree, I in all probability would’ve gone with #22, and been shocked if it have been prime 20.
For it to be prime 10 is downright stunning. This places it in the identical league as Tiana’s Bayou Journey, TRON Lightcycle Run, Haunted Mansion, Seven Dwarfs Mine Prepare, and Pirates of the Caribbean. (I assume these rankings aren’t counting leisure, as there’s no method Nation Bear Musical Jamboree is #6 if we’re throwing Fortunately Ever After, Competition of Fantasy, and so on. into the combo.)
In terms of the spike in visitor satisfaction for a experience reimagining, the one factor that instantly involves thoughts could be Maelstrom to Frozen Ever After. Even that wasn’t fairly as pronounced to one of the best of my information. (The spike for Guardians of the Galaxy: Cosmic Rewind was, however that’s not a reimagining that reused the identical experience system–it’s completely completely different, and fewer stunning.)
Stunned as I is perhaps, that is optimistic from my perspective.
Despite the fact that I personally wouldn’t rank Nation Bear Musical Jamboree 21 spots above the OG Nation Bear Jamboree (or perhaps a single spot), I’m not lamenting the poor style of my fellow friends. This implies a number of issues, all of that are excellent news. The primary is that the Nation Bears are “secure” for an additional couple of many years. I figured this was the case with the reimagining, however feared that if it have been shortly deemed a failure, they could plug the plug sooner.
The second is that this will increase the chance of seasonal overlays sooner or later. I nonetheless suppose Halloween and Christmas Nation Bear Musical Jamborees are unlikely, however this no less than strikes the needle a bit. It additionally presents a problem: discovering seasonal Disney IP that matches (as a result of that’ll be the lesson Disney realized from this).
Lastly, it proves longer and Audio Animatronics-centric sights nonetheless maintain immense enchantment. I’ve been saying this for years–and that it’s a idiot’s errand to chase know-how and traits, particularly through screens, as a result of everybody has these of their pockets.
Not solely that, however client know-how refreshes sooner than Disney, so there’s a hazard of every part wanting dated a lot sooner. A “blue ocean” technique, of types, in aiming for sights that can’t or will not be replicated wherever else is the optimum method.
Nation Bear Musical Jamboree is proof of idea on this, definitively demonstrating {that a} slower-paced and longer present pushed by Audio Animatronics and with out any thrills or gimmicks generally is a hit with friends. Not only a success, however a powerful one.
On a semi-related notice, a number of readers have requested for my assessment of Nation Bear Musical Jamboree after I uncared for to put in writing one final summer season. That was on goal, as I’ve difficult and conflicting emotions about this reimagining. I’ve joked about writing “Tom’s Completely Biased Nation Bear Musical Jamboree Evaluate” to share them.
This seems like nearly as good of a spot as any for that. I’ll begin with the objectively optimistic, which is that Grizzly Corridor appears to be like and sounds nice. The eye put into the shows within the ready space is great, the form of loving tribute to the bears that has existed for years at Tokyo Disneyland. (Okay, not fairly that good.)
Then there are the bears themselves. In addition they look and sound nice–and I don’t imply the music. The rebuilt Audio Animatronics are fluid and don’t make a ton of noise whereas transferring. The coats look contemporary and improbable. From the angle of present high quality alone, Nation Bear Musical Jamboree is head and shoulders above the OG Nation Bear Jamboree.
After all, it didn’t have to be that method–the previous present may’ve obtained TLC over time, it simply didn’t. Nothing was stopping Disney from greenlighting a restoration of the attraction, however realistically, hundreds of thousands of {dollars} aren’t spent like that on legacy sights with no marketable return. The underside line, although, is that the present appears to be like and sounds higher than it has at any time in my grownup life. Once more, that is Tokyo Disneyland-esque, however on this case, Nation Bear Musical Jamboree outperforms its Japanese counterpart.
Making an attempt to predominant my objectivity, I’m extra combined on the present itself. It’s very troublesome to put aside my private preferences in humor and music, each of which skew strongly in favor of the OG Nation Bear Jamboree. On the similar time, the truncated present misplaced a whole lot of its luster over a decade in the past.
What I can say is that a number of of the Disney songs labored higher than I anticipated, and there’s sufficient humor and rapport among the many bears to convey their attraction, character, and historical past. It feels cohesive and well-paced. And once more, all of it feels very lovingly achieved by Imagineers who clearly “get” the Nation Bears as they executed an IP mandate.
My greatest criticism on the substantive facet (whereas making an attempt to be goal) is that there’s an excessive amount of genre-bending and script-flipping. It’s humorous or stunning the primary couple of instances that the foolish bears carry out a love track within the type of nation music, however feels gimmicky after a bit. I do know Disney doesn’t have a ton of nation music in its songbook, however I in all probability would’ve gone with extra music from The Lion King, Vehicles, Fox and the Hound, Tarzan, House on the Vary, or (particularly) Coco.
With that mentioned, it’s not as if the track choice is unhealthy by any means. I appreciated a lot of the music and accompanying gags (“Supercalifragilisticexpialiocious” and “A Complete New World” being my favorites). It simply felt like 1-2 songs too many making an attempt to be intelligent or shock audiences. (Reducing the Toy Story music is the best reply. Walt Disney World doesn’t want this a lot Toy Story.)
As for the biased a part of the assessment, we’ve largely been over this earlier than.
There are a few new developments, although. The primary is in speaking to extra folks with information of the decision-making course of that resulted within the Nation Bear Musical Jamboree reimagining. That is one thing I hinted at beforehand, arguing that it in all probability wasn’t OG Nation Bear Jamboree vs. Nation Bear Musical Jamboree, however quite, Nation Bear Musical Jamboree vs. no bears in any respect.
Every thing I’ve heard for the reason that announcement means that that is 100% correct. That it took years for Nation Bear Musical Jamboree to get the greenlight, and it virtually by no means occurred. (One of many uncommon circumstances the place possibly the COVID closure improved outcomes.) That the present was a hard-fought victory for the passionate creatives who love the Nation Bears. That this was one of the best case situation of the outcomes that have been really believable. Fan daydreams a couple of restored Nation Bear Jamboree are good, however they have been simply that–daydreams–not something realistically thought-about.
This isn’t to say you need to agree with the choice at a excessive degree, as a result of clearly, you don’t. However I really feel unhealthy for the Imagineers and others on the undertaking who have been criticized by followers for “killing” the OG Nation Bear Jamboree. These followers have it precisely backwards–these creatives and leaders went above and past to save lots of the Nation Bears from a worse destiny: extinction.
All of that makes reviewing Nation Bear Musical Jamboree troublesome for me. I believe the present high quality is superior and recognize that the attraction has been modernized; it’ll introduce a complete new technology of friends to the Nation Bears, which is an effective factor. With background information, I’m happy with how this saga ended up taking part in out versus the choice. But when I simply assessment Nation Bear Musical Jamboree on its deserves in opposition to what it changed, I don’t come away pondering it’s an enchancment. A minimum of, not for me, personally.
Then there’s one more biasing issue. We took our daughter to see Nation Bear Musical Jamboree for the primary time, and she or he completely liked it. Megatron is just about a Nation Bear connoisseur, having now seen the unique present, Nation Bear Trip, Nation Bear Christmas, and Nation Bear Musical Jamboree.
She loves each single model, however Nation Bear Musical Jamboree obtained the most important response out of her. Actually, this isn’t all that outstanding. She doesn’t watch motion pictures but, so it’s not like she acknowledges these Disney songs. If something, she’s heard the music from Trip Hoedown and Jingle Bell Jamboree probably the most, as these comprise actual world music that we’ve listened to at dwelling.
For her, the enchantment is the bears, themselves–she likes to level at them, clap, and snicker. Regardless, Nation Bear Musical Jamboree is certainly one of Megatron’s favourite Disney sights on the earth…which makes it certainly one of my favorites, too.
I had seen CBMJ a number of instances over the prior months, however I used to be additional gained over primarily based on Sarah’s response to it. She went into this new present with a bit of, let’s say, cynicism, about it. Her expectations weren’t excessive. Sarah’s favourite variations of the present are the seasonal overlays, and she or he was skeptical the IP injection may preserve and attraction and spirit of the decades-old exhibits. She walked away pleasantly shocked. She really wished to do it a number of extra instances, whereas OG Nation Bear Jamboree at Magic Kingdom had fallen to once-per-visit standing.
That was kind of my response to seeing Nation Bear Musical Jamboree for the primary time, and I believe seeing our daughter getting so giddy concerning the bears heightened Sarah’s personal response. It actually did mine, and underscored that we’d be capable of benefit from the Nation Bears with Megatron for years to come back, which nearly was not the result in Magic Kingdom. From that perspective alone, I give very excessive–however very biased–marks to Nation Bear Musical Jamboree. I’d think about our opinions will solely grow to be extra favorable as Megatron acknowledges extra of the music from the present, and we kind household nostalgia for Nation Bear Musical Jamboree.
Planning a Walt Disney World journey? Find out about resorts on our Walt Disney World Motels Critiques web page. For the place to eat, learn our Walt Disney World Restaurant Critiques. To economize on tickets or decide which kind to purchase, learn our Ideas for Saving Cash on Walt Disney World Tickets put up. Our What to Pack for Disney Journeys put up takes a singular take a look at intelligent objects to take. For what to do and when to do it, our Walt Disney World Trip Guides will assist. For complete recommendation, one of the best place to start out is our Walt Disney World Journey Planning Information for every part you might want to know!
Your Ideas
What do you consider the reimagined Nation Bear Musical Jamboree? Stunned that it’s GSAT jumped from #27 to #6 throughout all of Magic Kingdom? Do you personally favor the OG Nation Bear Jamboree or CBMJ? Do you no less than perceive the upside of modernizing the attraction, even should you favor the unique? Do you agree or disagree with my evaluation? Any questions we can assist you reply? Listening to your suggestions—even if you disagree with us—is each fascinating to us and useful to different readers, so please share your ideas under within the feedback!
