Subscribe
Apple | Spotify | Amazon |iHeart Radio | Castbox | Podcast Republic | RSS | Patreon | Discord | Fb | IMDB
Podcast Transcript
For over a century, firms have tried to invent the following nice strategy to hearken to music or watch films.
Some turned family requirements that had been the inspiration of multi-billion-dollar industries. Others turned costly errors, technological lifeless ends, or punchlines within the historical past of client electronics.
Some had been so inconsequential that most individuals by no means even realized that they existed.
Be taught extra about failed media codecs and the battles behind them on this episode of Every little thing All over the place Day by day.
It’s surprising what number of completely different codecs firms have developed for listening to music and watching movies.
Many of the profitable codecs you already know of, in addition to a couple of of the unsuccessful ones. But there was a staggering variety of codecs developed that finally went nowhere.
A few of them had been simply applied sciences forward of their time, some had been too costly, and others simply weren’t excellent.
In actual fact, there are such a lot of that I couldn’t probably cowl all of them. So, for the aim of this episode, I’m solely going to cowl media codecs for music and video, not laptop knowledge storage.
Additionally, the time period “failed” is a bit ambiguous, so I’m not protecting something that was the dominant media format for any interval. Which means vinyl information, reel-to-reel tapes, cassette tapes, VHS, DVD, and Blu-ray won’t be included.
So with that, let’s get began with one you most likely by no means heard of, the primary client video recording system, Cartrivision.
Cartrivision was an early house videocassette system launched in 1972, earlier than VHS and Betamax. It was constructed into giant console televisions and allowed customers to document TV applications, whereas additionally providing prerecorded function movies for rental, making it one of many first client movie-rental codecs. Adjusted for inflation, the system value round $10,000.
Its rental tapes had a primitive copy-protection system: they might be performed however not rewound at house, so that they needed to be returned after viewing. The system was costly, cumbersome, and short-lived, and it disappeared after a few yr as gross sales did not take off.
Oddly sufficient, in 2013, the misplaced Recreation 5 of the 1973 NBA Championship sport was discovered on a Cartrivision tape. Recovering it was so troublesome {that a} documentary was made about it.
One other media format that achieved some restricted recognition within the Seventies was the 8-track tape.
The 8-track tape got here to be as a result of it solved a really particular downside: easy methods to deliver recorded music into the automotive.
There had been makes an attempt to create in-car document gamers and tape programs, however they had been awkward, fragile, or unreliable. The breakthrough got here from the endless-loop tape cartridge.
As a substitute of threading tape between reels like a reel-to-reel machine, the tape was packed inside a plastic cartridge and performed constantly. You might shove it right into a dashboard participant, hear music immediately, and never fear about flipping sides.
The format was refined by Invoice Lear, the identical Lear behind Learjet, who labored with earlier cartridge designs and helped standardize the 8-track system within the mid-Nineteen Sixties. Its huge business break got here when Ford started providing 8-track gamers in vehicles.
I hesitated placing 8-track tapes on this record as a result of they had been really fairly common for some time. I distinctly keep in mind individuals shopping for and utilizing them once I was actually younger.
However the format had built-in weaknesses. As a result of the tape was an countless loop, it was susceptible to stretching, tangling, and carrying out. You might not simply rewind. Quick-forwarding was attainable on some gamers, however imprecise.
Songs generally needed to be break up awkwardly between tracks, that means a track would possibly fade out, the machine would click on, after which the track would fade again in.
It was quickly changed by the cassette tape, which rapidly improved in high quality. The cassette tape was smaller, extra sturdy, and have become insanely common with the discharge of the Sony Walkman.
I’ll briefly give a point out to the Sony Betamax tape, however solely briefly as a result of I beforehand did a complete episode on the competitors between VHS and Betamax.
I’ll simply point out that the usual story about Betamax being a superior format wasn’t fairly true. VHS gained as a result of it supplied one thing customers valued extra: recording size.
Throughout the time when each VHS and Betamax had been vying for market supremacy, RCA launched its personal video format, which was an costly, whole catastrophe: RCA’s SelectaVision.
SelectaVision was probably the most costly and embarrassing failures within the historical past of client electronics. The title was used for a couple of RCA video tasks, however it’s best remembered for the CED, or Capacitance Digital Disc, system.
It was a house video format that saved films on grooved vinyl-like discs, which had been learn by a stylus slightly than by a laser. The discs got here sealed in giant plastic caddies, so the person by no means dealt with the discs immediately. You inserted the caddy into the participant, the machine pulled the disc out, and the empty caddy got here again out.
The fundamental concept was to create a less expensive various to videotape. Within the Seventies, VCRs had been nonetheless costly, and RCA believed there could be a big marketplace for a lower-cost system that might play prerecorded films at house.
Nevertheless, the system suffered from a deadly timing downside. RCA spent effectively over a decade growing it, and by the point SelectaVision lastly reached the market in 1981, VHS and Betamax had already established themselves.
Not like a VCR, SelectaVision couldn’t document tv applications, which was one of many greatest causes individuals purchased house video machines within the first place.
Essentially the most superb factor about SelectaVision was that it labored. There are some movies on YouTube that present it in motion, and the standard is best than you’d assume for one thing that was enjoying video from a vinyl disc.
RCA discontinued SelectaVision in 1984, solely three years after launch. The corporate reportedly misplaced a whole lot of tens of millions of {dollars} on the mission. In hindsight, it’s a basic instance of an organization fixing yesterday’s downside.
RCA had constructed a intelligent strategy to play films at house, however it arrived after customers had already determined they needed to document, time-shift, hire, and finally personal films on videotape.
One other video disc expertise that by no means made it huge was LaserDisc.
LaserDisc was probably the most fascinating almost-successes in house video historical past. First launched commercially within the late Seventies by MCA, Phillips, and Pioneer, it was an optical disc format that saved video on giant, 12-inch discs roughly the dimensions of vinyl information.
Not like VHS or Betamax, which used magnetic tape, LaserDisc was learn with a laser, making it a forerunner of later optical codecs reminiscent of DVD and Blu-ray. It needs to be famous that regardless of utilizing a laser, it was analog, not digital.
Its nice power was high quality. LaserDisc supplied higher image and sound than VHS, and it turned particularly common with severe movie followers, collectors, and residential theater lovers.
It was additionally the format that helped introduce many options that later turned customary on DVDs, together with widescreen editions, director’s commentaries, bonus options, alternate audio tracks, and high-quality particular editions. For individuals who cared about films as films, LaserDisc was far forward of videotape.
There have been additionally digital codecs that failed as effectively. Probably the greatest-known failed codecs was Digital Audio Tape, or DAT.
Digital Audio Tape was launched by Sony within the late Nineteen Eighties as a high-quality digital successor to analog cassette tape. It used small cassette-like cartridges, however in contrast to odd cassettes, it recorded sound digitally. The audio high quality was wonderful, usually at or above CD high quality, and the tapes had been compact, sturdy, and able to making very clear recordings.
Technically, DAT was spectacular. It used a rotating-head system much like a video recorder, permitting it to retailer a considerable amount of digital info on a slender strip of tape.
Due to this, DAT turned common in skilled settings, particularly in recording studios, radio, movie manufacturing, and dwell live performance recording. For musicians and engineers, it was a handy strategy to make digital grasp recordings earlier than hard-drive recording turned widespread.
Its downside was the buyer market. The music trade was deeply fearful that DAT would enable individuals to make excellent digital copies of CDs, so there have been political and authorized fights over copy safety.
This delayed adoption led to restrictions such because the Serial Copy Administration System, which restricted digital copying. On the similar time, DAT machines had been costly, and most odd listeners had little purpose to exchange CDs or cassettes with one other tape-based format.
One more failed Sony format was the MiniDisc.
MiniDisc was Sony’s early-Nineties try to exchange each cassette tapes and the CD. It used a small magneto-optical disc housed in a protecting plastic cartridge, making it a lot harder and extra transportable than a CD.
Customers might document, erase, rearrange tracks, title songs, and make clear digital copies throughout the limits of Sony’s copy-protection guidelines. In some ways, it was what individuals had all the time needed cassettes to be: small, sturdy, recordable, and simple to edit.
The format had actual strengths. It was common with journalists, musicians, college students, and audio hobbyists as a result of transportable MiniDisc recorders had been wonderful for area recording.
In Japan, it turned a significant client format, particularly for transportable music. Sony later improved the system with higher compression, longer recording modes, and finally Hello-MD, which elevated storage capability and allowed use as a disc for laptop knowledge.
However MiniDisc struggled within the wider world market as a result of it arrived at a clumsy time. CDs had been already low cost and dominant, recordable CDs turned widespread, after which MP3 gamers made the entire concept of carrying bodily music discs really feel outdated.
Sony additionally harm the format with the identical mistake it made with digital audio tape: it in-built excessively restrictive software program and duplicate controls, making it much less handy than merely dragging MP3 information onto a participant.
MiniDisc was not a nasty format. It was a intelligent, sturdy, near-success that acquired trapped between the CD period and the iPod period.
There have been additionally a number of failed makes an attempt at digital audio codecs that had been of upper high quality than common CDs.
DVD-Audio was a high-resolution audio format launched within the yr 2000 as a attainable successor to the compact disc. It used DVD discs to retailer music at a lot greater high quality than customary CDs, usually with encompass sound mixes in addition to stereo tracks. For audiophiles, it supplied spectacular sound and extra storage capability than a CD.
Whereas CDs used 16-bit samples at a 44.1 kilohertz pattern fee, DVD-Audio might use 24-bit samples at a fee as excessive as 192 kilohertz.
I really personal a number of DVD-Audio discs that I bought again then. There’s a particular enchancment in audio high quality, however it is vitally delicate, and also you want the appropriate tools to essentially hear it. I not too long ago put one in my Blu-ray participant, and it performed wonderful.
Nevertheless, DVD-Audio was launched concurrently a high-quality audio format, Tremendous Audio Compact Disc, or SACD.
SACD was created by Philips and Sony, the businesses that developed the Compact Disc customary.
SACD took a completely new strategy. As a substitute of 16 or 24-bit samples, SACD used a one-bit pattern. Every 1 represented up of the sound wave, and every 0 represented down. Nevertheless, it did this one-bit sampling at a fee of over 2.8 megahertz.
SACD additionally supplied a multilayer disc with an everyday CD layer and a SACD layer.
The issue with each of those excessive finish audio codecs is that they each appeared within the market proper when MP3s and Napster had been peaking in recognition. This turned out to be the substitute for CDs, not the next high quality disc.
There may be an odd twist to the story nevertheless. SACD by no means turned a mainstream substitute for the CD, however it didn’t utterly disappear. It survived as a distinct segment audiophile and classical music format, the place sound high quality mattered greater than portability or comfort.
An inexpensive estimate is that the market now sees roughly 500 to 700 new SACD titles per yr worldwide. Numerous these are classical titles, primarily bought in Japan. Additionally they don’t have very giant print runs, to allow them to be arduous to search out and are sometimes bought at a premium.
Some say that each bodily media format is now out of date, as the whole lot is obtainable on-line through streaming.
Nevertheless, that isn’t completely true. There was an uptick in bodily media gross sales over the previous couple of years as individuals have realized that music and flicks aren’t all the time out there on streaming providers.
There are even restricted numbers of recent 8-track and reel-to-reel tapes which are nonetheless being launched, primarily to hobbyists.
There would possibly by no means be a brand new bodily media format. Present gross sales are too small to justify investments in new codecs, and the outdated codecs are ok.
